20160608 - e-SENS eP/PS, Towards Piloting Stage - Meeting minutes: Wednesday, June 8th 2016

Date

08 Jun 2016 12:00 CEST - 13:00 CEST

Duration: 30min

Agenda

1) Status Point of each MS

2) AOB

Attendees

• João Gonçalves (PT)
• Massimiliano Massi (AT)
• Marcello Melgara (IT)
• Luca Pagliara (IT)
• Pierluigi Miglioli (IT)

• Younes Djaghloul (LU)

Invited Members

• João Gonçalves (PT)
• Licinio Kustra Mano (PT, Domain Pilot Architect)
• João Marques (PT)
• Raquel Vilas (PT)
• Celia Varela (ES)
• Juan Pablo Martinez (ES)
• Maria Jesús Macías (ES)
• Marcello Melgara (IT)
• Robert Scharinger (AT)
• Massimiliano Massi (AT)
• François Wisniewski (LU)

• Younes Djaghloul (LU)

• Dimitrios Katehakis (e-SENS WP5.2 Contact Person)
• Ioannis Petrakis (e-SENS WP5.2 Contact Person - assistant)

• George Pangalos (GR)

• Zoi Kolitsi (GR)

• Christina Papakonstantinou (GR - New Pilot Contact Point for these meetings)

• Athanasios Siachoudis (GR)
  

Goals

• Overview on the progress of each MS towards the Piloting Stage. Special focus on the preparation for Lisbon's 2016 eHealth Summer Week demonstrations, namely providing answers to the following set of questions:
  1. Which OpenNCP version are you running?
  2. What is your status regarding BB adoption?
  3. Can eID level 3 identify a patient from your country? (i.e., can we demonstrate eID level 3 using a card from your country?)
  4. To which countries are you VPN-connected (special focus on connectivity to Portugal)?
  5. Have you updated your endpoints and/or certificates recently? If so, have you uploaded the new configurations to the Central Services hosted by EC?
  6. Have you performed NCP-2-NCP testing recently?
  7. Which services does your country provide (eP/PS A and B)?
  8. For those providing PS-A: How many samples? Is their data clinically meaningful or completely dummy?
• Discuss technical/non-technical issues identified by each MS
  
  

Related Documents

• e-SENS_WP5_2_PilotingRoadmap_V2.ppt
• eSENS_MS_ProgressReport_template_V2.xlsx
• 20150609 eP-PS Testing_Strategy V1.pptx

Discussion items

1) Status Point of each MS:

LEGEND:

• CONNECTIVITY
  • Y: Yes; 
  • W: Working on it. 
  • ?: We can assume yes due to other PN statement, but still missing PN statement
• SERVICES
  • YES: as planned;
  • maybe: if things work alright, but not part of the original plan.

Answers to questions listed in the Goals:

PT:

1. Which OpenNCP version are you running?
   1. 2.4.0 - RC1 (except Portal). Currently in the process of upgrading to 2.4.1.
2. What is your status regarding BB adoption?
   1. Non-rep, eID level 1, SMP/SML upload
3. Can eID level 3 identify a patient from your country? (i.e., can we demonstrate eID level 3 using a card from your country?)
   1. Yes
4. To which countries are you VPN-connected (special focus on connectivity to Portugal)?
   1. AT
5. Have you updated your endpoints and/or certificates recently? If so, have you uploaded the new configurations to the Central Services hosted by EC?
   1. Yes. Yes. The notification about the new Portuguese TSL-file was circulated amongst the last OpenNCP Bi-weekly meeting minutes.
6. Have you performed NCP-2-NCP testing recently?
   1. Yes, with AT.
7. Which services does your country provide (eP/PS A and B)?
   1. PS-A, PS-B
8. For those providing PS-A: How many samples? Is their data clinically meaningful or completely dummy?
   1. At least 2. Clinically meaningful for 1 of them, the other(s) needs to be checked.

IT:

1. Which OpenNCP version are you running?
   1. OpenNCP V2.4.0, released before EXPAND-a-Thon, planning to install V2.4.1, but before we have to fix many local issues.
2. What is your status regarding BB adoption?
   
   1. Non-rep, SMP/SML upload, eID level 1 (included in Lombardy Portal) but we want to extend to other levels (but not yet implemented).
3. Can eID level 3 identify a patient from your country? (i.e., can we demonstrate eID level 3 using a card from your country?)
   1. YES
4. To which countries are you VPN-connected (special focus on connectivity to Portugal)?

   1. In the past we were connected to: PT, LU, MT, GR, CH. We have new certificates to be installed.

5. Have you updated your endpoints and/or certificates recently? If so, have you uploaded the new configurations to the Central Services hosted by EC?

   1. YES updated, not uploaded, yet. Luca was able to download the key today, in the past was not possible. We should now be in a position to use TSL-sync/editor with the new EC Central Services. In the past we could work with the TSL-file from MT and GR, but we had issues with the other files. Now: we're focusing on generating the new configuration file and synchronizing.

6. Have you performed NCP-2-NCP testing recently?
   1. NO
7. Which services does your country provide (eP/PS A and B)?
   1. PS/A, PS/B, eP/A (currently not available for pharma-db issues). Let's concentrate on PS for the moment.
8. For those providing PS-A: How many samples? Is their data clinically meaningful or completely dummy?
   1. Real data, but needs to be revised. We have 1 PS that is 100% real (from Marcello). The others we'll try to make them as reasonable as possible. We still have the issue of the coded data for medicinal, still not operational. Our PS will be fine.

For Lisbon, we're not sure if we could to fetch IT PS with eID level 3. We can try with Marcello's card.

LU:

1. Which OpenNCP version are you running?

   1. Planning to install V2.4.1

2. What is your status regarding BB adoption?
   1. Non-repudiation
3. Can eID level 3 identify a patient from your country? (i.e., can we demonstrate eID level 3 using a card from your country?)

   1. No

4. To which countries are you VPN-connected (special focus on connectivity to Portugal)?

   1. PT, CH. We may need to install new certificates retrieved from ICA. What happens due to the missing adoption of the new central services ?

5. Have you updated your endpoints and/or certificates recently? If so, have you uploaded the new configurations to the Central Services hosted by EC?

   1. No not yet updated, not uploaded, yet

6. Have you performed NCP-2-NCP testing recently?
   1. NO
7. Which services does your country provide (eP/PS A and B)?
   1. PS/A, PS/B
8. For those providing PS-A: How many samples? Is their data clinically meaningful or completely dummy?
   1. Dummy test data

Note: François provided the answers by email.

AT:

1. Which OpenNCP version are you running?
   1. 2.4.0
2. What is your status regarding BB adoption?
   1. SMP/SML upload, Non-rep, eID level 3. Comment from Massi: Non-rep implementation has a bug. The message received by OpenNCP and passed to the REM evidence emitter is changing. Massi hopes to check what to do, so a new version of the util package is expected: UT-19 - Getting issue details... STATUS
3. Can eID level 3 identify a patient from your country? (i.e., can we demonstrate eID level 3 using a card from your country?)
   1. YES
4. To which countries are you VPN-connected (special focus on connectivity to Portugal)?
   1. PT. Will begin testing with IT in the next days.
5. Have you updated your endpoints and/or certificates recently? If so, have you uploaded the new configurations to the Central Services hosted by EC?
   1. Certificates were created before EXPANDathon. Already uploaded.
6. Have you performed NCP-2-NCP testing recently?
   1. PT. Will begin testing with IT in the next days.
7. Which services does your country provide (eP/PS A and B)?
   1. PS/eP A and B. For Lisbon we should concentrate on PS.
8. For those providing PS-A: How many samples? Is their data clinically meaningful or completely dummy?
   1. 3 PS. Meaningful for the last epSOS projectathon (2012), but not valid anymore after changes made by EXPAND, so it's dummy.

Feels confident about demonstration of PS workflow in Lisbon with eID level 3.

ES:

1. Which OpenNCP version are you running?
2. What is your status regarding BB adoption?
3. Can eID level 3 identify a patient from your country? (i.e., can we demonstrate eID level 3 using a card from your country?)
4. To which countries are you VPN-connected (special focus on connectivity to Portugal)?
5. Have you updated your endpoints and/or certificates recently? If so, have you uploaded the new configurations to the Central Services hosted by EC?
6. Have you performed NCP-2-NCP testing recently?
7. Which services does your country provide (eP/PS A and B)?
8. For those providing PS-A: How many samples? Is their data clinically meaningful or completely dummy?

Note: we didn't have Spain representatives in the meeting.

GR:

1. Which OpenNCP version are you running?
2. What is your status regarding BB adoption?
3. Can eID level 3 identify a patient from your country? (i.e., can we demonstrate eID level 3 using a card from your country?)
4. To which countries are you VPN-connected (special focus on connectivity to Portugal)?
5. Have you updated your endpoints and/or certificates recently? If so, have you uploaded the new configurations to the Central Services hosted by EC?
6. Have you performed NCP-2-NCP testing recently?
7. Which services does your country provide (eP/PS A and B)?
8. For those providing PS-A: How many samples? Is their data clinically meaningful or completely dummy?

Note: we didn't have Greece representatives in the meeting.

e-SENS Y4 Perspective

GR: Y4 FOCUS: Establish connectivity in PPT and test the NCP.  Implement what will be agreed in the eHN to be adopted at NCP tech layer;

• What is the benefit of piloting with "Real Patient Data"? Are we DEMANDED to reach 
• What is the value of reach "Technology Operation Readiness" level?
• Recommended approach to eID in Y4:
• • Brainstorm and consolidate technical solutions for eID, matching eIDAS requirements, and technology each PN is able to pilot;
  • Align and gather inputs from JAseHN eID task, regarding how to fulfil the need and requirements towards eID for Patient Identification.
  • Use April 19th Workshop: to be bring the right people together to think and plan eID for Patient Identification approach during e-SENS Y4

LU: Y4 FOCUS: 

• Understand which other BB from e-SENS may enhance the NCPeH and be experimented, to be used in CEF;

IT: Y4 FOCUS:  

• 1st: Will we have "Real Patient Data"? If yes, need to have a consolidated process for legal agreement (e.g. TLA is or not enough);
  • Who MS will go live with real patient data.
• 2nd: Keep NCPeH updated. Are there specific BB that allow to solve IT national challenges (e.g. eID for Physicians)? To facilitate the alignement with the future CEF DSI.

PT: Y4 FOCUS: 

• Finnish the SMP/SML integration (namely by adopting EC server);
• Complete integration of eID Level 2 and Level 3 (using Countries Accreditation Servers instead of the current Fraunhofer test server)
• Integrate, test and adopt eIDLevel 4 & 5.
• Have all the MS piloting exchanging PS and eP, data on Pre-Operation environment;

2) AOB & Next Meeting

Marcello will be in ValueHealth meeting in the 15th of June, so will not be able to join. Luca or Pierluigi may be able to attend.

• Joao Cunha: Prepare and disseminate today minutes, Schedule e-SENS Piloting MS Meeting by 15 Jun 2016 12:00 CET
• Joao Cunha: Progress and Issues report to e-SENS WP5.2.1 Management